Jane's Aerospace Defense and Security Blog

Beyond the State: Islamic State’s territorial losses expected to result in a substantially increased terrorism threat for Europe




Key points:

  • The Islamic State will lose its remaining territory in Iraq and Syria, but is highly likely to transition into a shadow state and underground insurgency, while continuing to undermine security and stability through constant low-level violence and periodic mass-casualty operations, particularly in Iraq.
  • For European security, returning foreign fighters and their families will present both immediate and long-term challenges, increasing the terrorism threat on the continent significantly in the ten-year outlook.
  • A wider outcome of the Islamic State’s decline is the potential resurgence of existing groups such as Al Qaeda.

The Islamic State’s existence as a territory holding organisation in Iraq and Syria will likely come to an end within 12 months, changing the group’s nature significantly. According to Conflict Monitor, since the start of 2017 the Islamic State’s territory has quickly reduced by 40%, while its revenues have dropped by 80%. At current rates of territorial loss, the group will have only residual territorial influence from late 2017 onwards and is unlikely to remain in control of areas before its fourth year comes to a close in June 2018.

However, the loss of territory will not mark the end of the Islamic State as a militant organisation. In all likelihood, the group will transition from a pseudo-state to an underground armed insurgency and remain able to conduct asymmetric attacks against security forces in both Iraq and Syria, continuing to undermine security and central governance. Additionally, it will seek to maintain some semblance of its former governance structure as a shadow state, carrying out summary justice through abductions and executions and portraying itself as exercising power in areas under government control. 

International element

Since the establishment of the Islamic State on 29 June 2014, the group has actively called for retaliatory attacks against Western civilian and military personnel in their home countries.

Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Centre (JTIC) has recorded 32 attacks attributed to the Islamic State across 11 countries in Europe between 13 November 2015 and 18 August 2017, killing a total of at least 323 people and wounding at least 794. This has included attacks conducted by small cells or lone actors with varying, usually minimal, levels of connection to and support from the group.

Sectarian tensions across Iraq, and to an extent in Syria, will enable the group to continue waging an armed campaign and undermine security in its heartlands, but the group will also continue to focus on planning, facilitating, and encouraging attacks internationally to maintain its relevance and influence globally. This will also be hoped to inspire more lone actors, who’s small-scale but frequent attacks will help keep the notion of the Islamic State alive and active. The international element’s importance for the Islamic State will increase as its focus in Iraq and Syria shifts back towards insurgency in the wake of large-scale territorial losses.

Reverberations in Europe: foreign fighters and other returnees will transform the terrorism threat

The conflicts in Iraq and Syria and the rise of the Islamic State have defined a generation of militant Islamists in the region and abroad. Across Europe, they have motivated around 5,000 men to travel to participate in the conflict and become foreign fighters, while in many cases spouses and underage children have also immigrated to the group’s territories alongside the men. Many children have also been born in Iraq and Syria within the Islamic State’s territory to foreign fighters.

The potential return of these communities en masse from the conflict zones presents the most significant driver of Islamist terrorism in Europe in both the short and long term. Returning combat-experienced militants will pose an immediate security threat in the short term, while the wider communities associated with those fighters will present long-term challenges for the radicalisation of a new generation of militant Islamists.

De-radicalisation efforts must focus across the family unit

While counter-terrorism efforts must primarily focus on foreign fighters most likely to conduct attacks, any de-radicalisation programmes implemented by European countries to specifically deal with returnees should ensure that the wives and children of foreign fighters are actively included within their remit. In its Rumiyah magazine, published monthly since September 2016, an increasing number of features have focused on women’s roles in the Islamic State’s battle; on supporting their husbands’ work as militants; on tending to and “reforming” her children and encouraging them to engage in combat and aspire to martyrdom; and even on participating in combat when it was required. A failure to include this segment of society in a plan to mitigate Islamist militancy in Europe would be to allow an indoctrinated core segment of Islamist communities to continue facilitating the radicalisation of a new generation of potential militant Islamists. At present, most countries will lack an effective program for dealing with returning foreign fighters, and legislation across European countries differs as to whether travelling to Syria or Iraq to join a group gives grounds for arrest or not.

Power vacuum may lead to resurgence of Al-Qaeda

The Islamic State’s decline will have significant impacts on how the terrorism threat develops both in the group’s heartlands in Iraq and Syria and around the world. For global militant Islamism, the group’s campaign in Iraq and Syria has created a legacy that will continue to inspire militancy for years to come. In Europe, returning foreign fighters and their families will present one of the key drivers of the developing terrorism threat in the five- to ten-year outlook, with these individuals crystallising the Islamic State’s legacy for local Islamist communities and militant networks in Europe. More widely, the Islamic State’s decline will likely open up a vacuum, in which the role of Al-Qaeda will increase markedly; how the relationship between Al-Qaeda and the Islamic State develops will have direct implications for international terrorism, and will be a key indicator of the form attacks in the West will take in the future.

The content from this blog post is compiled from Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Centre. To request a demonstration or for more information visit Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Centre

Otso Iho, Senior Analyst, Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Centre 
Posted 13 September 2017

About The Author

Senior Analyst Country Risk – Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Centre (JTIC)

Otso Iho is a Senior Analyst at the Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Centre, covering terrorism on a global scale. He joined IHS Markit after spending two years at risk consultancy PGI Intelligence, where he provided analysis on security and business risk for clients primarily in the Oil & Gas, Mining, Maritime & Shipping, and Aviation sectors. Prior to PGI, Otso worked as an analyst at the IHS Markit Jane’s Aerospace, Defence & Security consulting team. He has also worked for Control Risks Group and the International Centre for Security Analysis at the King’s Policy Institute, working on corporate investigations and nuclear security & non-proliferation, respectively.

Otso has been invited to speak to law enforcement, defence, and government personnel on terrorism and security issues at a number of events, including the Counter-Terrorism Regional Leaders’ Forum in Thailand, the CBRNe World Convergence in the United States, and the Royal United Services Institute’s UK Project on Nuclear Issues in the United Kingdom. Over the course of five weeks in Southeast Asia and Australia over the past year, he has addressed more than 1,000 people in the national security and government sectors on terrorism threats posed by Islamist militancy in Southeast Asia. Most recently, he was heard as an expert witness for the Australian federal prosecution service in a terrorism case in Victoria, Australia, in May 2017.

Otso holds an MA in Terrorism, Security & Society from Kings College London (KCL), where he specialised in right-wing extremism, populist radical right social movements and anti-Muslim violence in Europe and the United States. He also holds a BA from University College London, where he focused on policing and the application of state violence in Russia and Eastern Europe. Otso speaks native Finnish, fluent English, limited working proficiency German, and elementary Hungarian.