Energy Blog

North American E&Ps: Dispelling debt bubble fears—an issue for a few, but not the many




During the oil boom, upstream companies financed rocketing production growth and sizable cash flow deficits with cheap money during a low interest rate environment. Who would not? Debt ballooned to unprecedented levels, and as oil prices collapsed, as many as 160 North American upstream companies declared bankruptcy or commenced strategic reviews.

As we emerge from the rubble of the 2014 oil price collapse, there remains a significant amount of debt on North American upstream oil and gas company balance sheets, raising investor concerns that companies might not be able to sustain capital spending and production growth. This report, utilizing IHS Markit fixed-income data, dispels the notion that serious debt issues are broad based. Instead, we believe that relatively few companies on our IHS Markit North American E&P coverage list are at high risk.

Analyzing Yield to maturity (YTM) between 2014 and 2017 show no cause for concern for 80% of the companies in the North American peer group; indeed, for a select group of companies, yields on bonds have declined. We divided the companies in this report into 4 distinct groups.

The first group’s average YTM increased from 6.5% to 18.5%, as investors recalibrated the price of risk for these troubled companies in a softer commodity environment. Companies in this group might find it difficult to access the debt market at reasonable yields.

Group 2 had a moderate increase in average YTM of 1 to 3 percentage points between 2014 and 2017. The average YTM for this group changed from 5.1% to 7.2%. The YTM change is manageable and does not represent considerable risk.

The third group had a minimal increase in average YTM of 1 percentage point or less between 2014 and 2017. These are well-established, large-cap companies with the balance sheet strength and operational depth to withstand weak commodity prices.

Group 4, surprisingly, had a decrease in average YTM of 1.5 percentage points on average between 2014 and 2017. Permian companies constitute the majority of this group along with well-established Marcellus companies. The Permian has emerged as the prime shale play in North America, offering multiple target formations, low costs, and steep growth prospects.

Anticipating rate increases by refinancing early: Many companies, were proactive, refinancing debt and pushing maturity dates further out— beyond five years. This was obviously prudent—not only because of weaker commodity prices, but also because the era of cheap money and low interest rates is expected to end. Collectively, the Large, Mid-sized, and Small E&P peer groups reduced principal debt due in the rolling five years by nearly 20%, from $80 billion in 2015 to $65 billion in 2016.

exploration and production peer groups principal debt

Figure 1: Change in principal due by year by peer group

Broad-based oil and gas securities markets signal stability: Debt investors also seem to have confidence in the broader oil & gas industry. Using proprietary IHS Markit proprietary indices that track oil and gas-focused company yield spreads to U.S. Treasuries confirm stability in the markets for both investment and noninvestment grade fixed-income securities.

YTM spread peaked at 1,800 basis points for noninvestment grade securities in early 2016, which coincided with the bottoming of oil prices at $33 per bbl. Yields for investment grade securities also peaked at that time, at 377 basis points.

Currently, with oil prices rallying and stabilizing in the $45–50 per bbl range, investment grade securities yields are lower than yields in early 2014 despite 50% lower oil prices. Yields on noninvestment grade securities are materially lower as well, at 525 basis points, but higher than the 400 basis point spread in early-to-mid-2014.

investment grade and high yield spreads

Figure 2: Investment grade and high yield spreads

Learn more about our offerings within companies & transactions research. 

Hassan Eltorie is Associate Director, Companies & Transactions Research at IHS Markit.
Posted 5 October 2017 

About The Author

Associate Director, Companies & Transactions Research

Hassan Eltorie is an Associate Director, Companies & Transactions Research at IHS Markit. He is responsible for equity analysis, valuations, and strategy assessment of large international E&Ps. Mr. Eltorie also develops financial models to measure the geopolitical risk of individual E&P companies, with recommendations on appropriate valuation methodologies and portfolio optimization. Prior to joining IHS in 2011, he spent five years in the corporate strategy and mergers and acquisitions group at Reliant Energy, helping guide the company’s strategy and executing asset and company acquisitions. Previous to that, he worked in investment banking and structured finance with Commercial International Bank and JPMorgan. Mr. Eltorie holds a BS from the American University in Cairo, Egypt, and an MBA from Rice University.